Rational Sciences and Methodology (Mantiq)

Books on logic (المنطق) and the methodology of reasoning, in Arabic: the matns studied in traditional curricula, their commentaries, and the treatises of adab al-bahth wa al-munazara, the discipline of structured debate. Definition, division, proposition, syllogism — the tools later used in usul al-fiqh and theology. Level and type of text stated on every listing. Real stock, dispatched within 24 to 48 hours.

No products available at the moment

Stay tuned! More products will be shown here as they are added.

Back to Home page

Why mantiq is on the syllabus

Mantiq is an instrumental science: it has no subject matter of its own, it governs how one defines, divides and concludes. It is studied because the sciences that follow, usul al-fiqh first among them, borrow its vocabulary and procedures: hadd and rasm, kulli and juz'i, qadiyya, qiyas with its figures. Without these notions a chapter of usul stays opaque. Its status has been debated by scholars across history; in the curricula that teach it, it comes after language and before the fundamentals.

The matns of the curriculum

Isaghuji (إيساغوجي) by al-Abhari: the entry text, very short, on the five universals and the basics of definition.
Al-Sullam al-munawraq (السلم المنورق) by al-Akhdari: a poem of about a hundred and forty verses, the most widespread in institutes, studied with the classical commentaries including that of al-Damanhuri.
Tahdhib al-mantiq (تهذيب المنطق) by al-Taftazani: a dense intermediate abridgement.
Al-Risala al-shamsiyya (الرسالة الشمسية) by al-Katibi al-Qazwini: the advanced reference treatise.

Adab al-bahth wa al-munazara

A distinct discipline, often shelved with logic: it sets the rules of scholarly discussion — what counts as an admissible objection, who carries the burden of proof, how a disagreement ends. The best-known text in contemporary curricula is that of Muhammad al-Amin al-Shanqiti. It is a short subject with immediate returns for anyone reading works of disputation or comparison between schools, for instance in fiqh.

Matn, commentary, gloss: what you are buying

As with grammar, three levels of text circulate under one title. The matn is made to be memorised and does not explain itself; the sharh is what you study with; the hashiya assumes the commentary is already mastered. Every listing states which it is, the commentator's name, the editorial work on the text and the page count, so that nobody buys a bare matn thinking they are buying a course.

The other instrumental sciences

Mantiq comes after language: Arabic grammar and morphology first, since a logic matn is written in a dense register that assumes i'rab is in hand. Rhetoric is studied alongside. The texts themselves are often found in the collections of the Arabic language matns section, and the order in which to take them up is covered in Learning methodology.

Ordering and shipping

Quantities shown are stock on the shelf, not a supplier lead time. Dispatched within 24 to 48 working hours, shipped across Europe and worldwide. For an institute booklist or a choice between two editions, write to us before ordering.

What is the point of studying mantiq?

To define, divide and conclude correctly. It is an instrumental science: the sciences that follow, usul al-fiqh first among them, borrow its vocabulary and procedures. Without these notions a chapter of usul is hard to follow.

Which text should I start with?

With al-Abhari's Isaghuji, very short, then al-Akhdari's Al-Sullam al-munawraq with a commentary. The Sullam is the most widespread text in institutes: a short poem, memorisable, and several accessible commentaries exist.

When should it be taken up?

After language. A logic matn is written in a dense register, with technical terms and compressed phrasing: without nahw and sarf you stumble on the sentence before you stumble on the idea. In the curricula that teach it, it comes after grammar and before the fundamentals.

What is adab al-bahth wa al-munazara?

The discipline that sets the rules of scholarly discussion: what counts as an admissible objection, who carries the burden of proof, how a disagreement is concluded. A short subject, immediately useful to anyone reading works of disputation or comparison between schools.

Do your editions include a commentary?

It depends on the title, and we state it on every listing: bare matn, matn with commentary, or commentary with gloss. To study, take a matn with a commentary; the bare matn is for memorisation once the text is understood.