Narrator Biographies and Criticism

Why a whole science for the narrators

A hadith is judged first by its chain, and a chain is worth what the men in it are worth. Hence a discipline that produced hundreds of volumes for a single question: who was this person, whom did they hear, who heard them, and what did the critics say about them. That is jarh wa ta'dil, the criticism of transmitters, and it is what makes hadith science verifiable rather than declarative.

The reference works

• Taqrib al-tahdhib by Ibn Hajar: one line per narrator, with a condensed verdict and the generation. In one or two volumes, it is the tool you open daily.
• Tahdhib al-tahdhib by the same author: the expansion of the above, in about twelve volumes.
• Tahdhib al-kamal by al-Mizzi: the compilation on the narrators of the six books, around thirty-five volumes, from which the two above derive.
• Al-Kashif by al-Dhahabi: a manageable abridgement of Tahdhib al-kamal.

The works of criticism

• Mizan al-i'tidal by al-Dhahabi: devoted to criticised narrators, with the imams' statements.
• Lisan al-Mizan by Ibn Hajar: completes the above for narrators outside the six books.
• Al-Jarh wa al-ta'dil by Ibn Abi Hatim: a major early source, nine volumes.
• Al-Tarikh al-kabir by al-Bukhari and Kitab al-thiqat by Ibn Hibban: the foundations of the genre.
• Al-Kamil fi du'afa al-rijal by Ibn 'Adi: on weak narrators, with the hadiths that prompted the criticism.

Biography in the broader sense

Siyar a'lam al-nubala by al-Dhahabi goes beyond the technical frame: a history of the scholars in twenty-five volumes, readable for its own sake, which sets the narrators back in their time. Ibn Sa'd's Tabaqat plays the same role for the first generations. These works interest the reader of history as much as the student of hadith.

Where to start

With Taqrib al-tahdhib, and with it alone. Learn to read its abbreviations and its scale of judgement, and you will know in thirty seconds what a name in a chain is worth. The large compilations come afterwards, and only if you genuinely work on isnads. The prerequisite notions are in Hadith sciences and terminology.

What to check before buying

The volume count and whether the edition is complete, since these titles also circulate truncated. The editor, more decisive here than anywhere: these texts are full of names, nisbas and dates, and a poorly established edition becomes dangerous. Finally the indexes, without which a thirty-volume rijal work is unusable. Every listing states these three points, the publisher and the binding.

Related sections

The prerequisite notions are in the hadith sciences. The use is on the chains of the collections and inside the commentaries that discuss an isnad. To gather all the routes of one hadith before comparing narrators, see the hadith encyclopaedias.

Ordering and shipping

Real stock shown. Sets are wrapped volume by volume and packed in a rigid box. Dispatched within 24 to 48 working hours, shipped across Europe and worldwide. For the total weight and the exact rate to your country, write to us before ordering.