Sira: modern studies

No products available at the moment

Stay tuned! More products will be shown here as they are added.

What the modern studies add

They do not replace the classical sources: they sift them and put them in order. A contemporary author sets aside the weak reports, establishes a chronology, adds maps and draws out the lessons of each episode. The result reads from end to end, which Ibn Hisham does not allow. In exchange, you read a selection and not the material.

The works on this shelf

Ar-Rahiq al-makhtum by Safiyyurrahman al-Mubarakfuri: the most widely circulated, in one volume, with a clear chronology and maps of the expeditions. The default choice here.
As-Sira an-nabawiyya as-sahiha by Akram Dhiya al-Umari: in two volumes, built on a critical examination of the sources. More demanding and more methodical.
Fiqh as-sira in its various versions: less a narrative than a reading of the lessons drawn from each stage.
The thematic studies: the expeditions, the treaty of Al-Hudaybiya, the wives, the organisation of Medina, treated separately.
The atlases of the sira, with routes and battle plans, read alongside a narrative.

How to choose between the two main ones

If the sira is new to you or you read Arabic without full ease, Ar-Rahiq al-makhtum: simple prose, a single volume, and an easy thread to follow. If you want to see how an author establishes his facts and sets a report aside, As-Sira an-nabawiyya as-sahiha is made for that. The language level is stated on each product page.

What to check

The language level, since the gap between the two titles above is real. The presence of maps, which changes a great deal in understanding the expeditions. The edition and the pagination, useful if you follow a course. And the binding on a thick volume. These points are on every product page.

Related shelves

To go back to the sources cited, Sira: the classical sources. For an even shorter format, Sira in one volume. For his personal description, Virtues of the Prophet ﷺ. For the hadiths cited along the way, Hadith. Overview: History.

Order and shipping

Real stock displayed, dispatch within 24 to 48 working hours, delivery to France, Europe and the rest of the world. Tell us your level of Arabic and we will say which of the two major titles suits you.

Ar-Rahiq al-makhtum or As-Sira an-nabawiyya as-sahiha?

Ar-Rahiq al-makhtum if you want a continuous read: one volume, simple prose, clear chronology and maps of the expeditions. As-Sira an-nabawiyya as-sahiha by Akram al-Umari if you want to see how an author establishes his facts: two volumes, more methodical, more demanding in language.

Do these works replace Ibn Hisham?

No, they sift him. A contemporary author sets aside the weak reports and puts the whole in order, but you are then reading a selection and not the material. If you must cite a fact with its source, you have to go back to the classical sources. The two shelves are separate for that reason.

Are the maps really useful?

On the expeditions, yes, and greatly. A battle narrative without a plan stays a sequence of place names, and the logic of a movement or a siege becomes clear as soon as you see it drawn. We flag the presence of maps on the product page, and the Historical geography shelf gathers the atlases that complete a narrative.

What is Fiqh as-sira?

A genre rather than a single title: several authors have published under that name. The principle is not to recount the events but to draw out their lessons, stage by stage. That assumes you already know the narrative, so it is not the first book to take on this shelf.