Sects and Schools in Islam | Al-Milal, Maqalat al-islamiyyin

No products available at the moment

Stay tuned! More products will be shown here as they are added.

A genre of its own: the maqalat

The literature of firaq wa maqalat arose from a concrete need: to record the positions in circulation, attribute them correctly and classify them. It belongs as much to the history of ideas as to theology. Its authors write from a position, and the good works say so; reading them usefully means knowing who is speaking. This is why we state the author's period and orientation on every listing.

The classical works

Maqalat al-islamiyyin by Abu al-Hasan al-Ash'ari: the earliest and most detailed survey of the positions, written in a descriptive style.
Al-Farq bayna al-firaq by Abd al-Qahir al-Baghdadi: arranged by group, with the history of how each formed.
Al-Milal wa al-nihal by al-Shahrastani: the most widely circulated; it goes beyond the Muslim frame and also treats religions and philosophies.
Al-Fasl fi al-milal wa al-ahwa wa al-nihal by Ibn Hazm: more polemical, and very rich in argument.
Al-I'tisam by al-Shatibi: a work of method rather than survey, devoted to the question of innovation and its criteria.
Talbis Iblis by Ibn al-Jawzi: a review of the failings he observed in various circles of his own time.

How to read these books

Three useful precautions. First, they are historical sources: they describe positions as they were understood in the author's time, not as present-day groups define themselves. Second, attributions vary from one author to another, and serious works flag those discrepancies. Third, this is advanced material: it assumes the basics of aqida are in place, failing which one retains labels without understanding what they cover.

Related sections

The basics are in Aqida matns and Aqida treatises. Works answering a thesis point by point are in Doctrinal refutations. For the general historical background, see History.

Ordering and shipping

Real stock shown, dispatched within 24 to 48 working hours, shipped across Europe and worldwide. For the volume count, the editor or the actual level of a title, write to us before ordering.

What are these works about?

They survey the currents of thought that appeared in Islamic history, set out their positions and trace how they formed. This is history of ideas as much as theology, and the best titles are those that attribute positions precisely.

Which title to start with?

Al-Milal wa al-nihal by al-Shahrastani is the most widely circulated and the most readable. Maqalat al-islamiyyin by al-Ash'ari is earlier and more detailed, but also more technical. Al-I'tisam by al-Shatibi is a work of method, of another kind.

Is a particular level needed?

Yes, an advanced one. These books assume the basics of aqida are in place; without them you retain labels without understanding what they cover. We state the level required on every listing.

Do these books describe present-day groups?

No, and that matters. They are historical sources: they describe positions as understood in the author's own time, not as contemporary groups define themselves. Transposing them directly leads to misreadings.

Are the authors neutral?

None is entirely, and the good works say so. Each author writes from a position, and attributions vary between books. This is why we state the author's period and orientation on every listing.

Sects and Schools of Thought